Well, if I'm allowed to go from what I've seen and read, Bioshock: Infinite for both platforms seems to be a strong early contender.

Definitely going with BioShock Infinite. As you said it's a little early to call this but that's such a great game.

I hadn't played many games from this year yet.  I want to get Skyrim and I actually started up Ni no Kuni, but haven't played enough of it to decide if I like it or not. 

For 360 it definitely has to be Bioshock Infinite. For the PS3 that is a tougher question. Most of the games I've bought for it lately are those HD collections which really don't count. But I'm going to say Crysis 3. Although I don't own it yet,I have played it for hours at a friends house last week. Very impressive running on the PS3. Skyrim would have been a great pick on any console. The digital copy you gave me is spectacular on my 360.

I'm actually planning to do a Game of the Year SO FAR blog closer to the middle of the year, around July or so.  I imagine by then, Animal Crossing: New Leaf will win. 

But right now, it looks like Ni no Kuni for PS3, BattleBlock Theater for 360, Toki Tori 2 for Wii U, and Luigi's Mansion for 3DS.

This may sound crazy but my pick is Maas Effect 3: Citadel DLC. The only time I've even considered putting DLC as GOTY but it was so good. After that either Sly 4 or Metal Gear Rising.

I agree actually it was freaking awesome and although I dont think dlc can take game of the year it is GOTY material.

I have to play some more of the new stuff before I can give a deffinative choice, but off the top of my head I'd say Dishonored. Load times kinda suck but the game play and atmosphere of this game are really impressive.

well i did say as of today not what you think it will be lol just hypothetecle speaking. and yea i know spelling check lol

Does the game have to come out this year to be goty lol

IF so then then idk, since i have not played any new games this year!

RE 6. lulz! But seriously, I have gotten a lot of replayability out of it.