Here's the selection if you are interested.
Torchlight for $2?! I wish I would have known about that sooner. I'm holding off on Diablo 3 simply because I haven't finished Torchlight 2. Thanks for the shares though!
Holy shit son. I'd recommend almost all of those games. If you haven't played it, The Cat Lady is a game you MUST experience. Whatever else you include on that list, add the cat lady, fuck me it's good.
I was contemplating Cat Lady. I only have Penumbra Overture so I was thinking about the expansion and the second game also. I don't know if I can find 3 more but I'll look.
The cat lady... dear god if you play it prepare for a dark andd disturbing game. I don't want to spoil anything. Unless you are easily disturbed, check this out. The story is amazing, And the voice acting is pretty awesome. I was blown away in some cases by it. Also... just bought the soundtrack... because holy shit it's amazing!
I'm already disturbed so that's not going to be a problem. ;) Put this way, If I can read Lovecraft, Clive Barker et al and not be disturbed does this game have a snowball's?
Is it a good thing or a bad thing that I've never heard of those games?
Well I can understand some of them but Alan Wake, you've never heard of Alan Wake? :)
Plus Stacking is on consoles too. I have it on PSN+, great game. Amnesia is arguably the scariest game ever made and gets talked about a lot in Survival Horror circles.
:shrugs: Is he the guy in Uncharted? =D
Yeah that's him. 
Grouchy Smurf: "I HATE FPS games."
But Setzer, Alan Wake is a Third Person Horror game. I'm so confused.
Grouchy Smurf: "I HATE Third Person Horror Survival Always Die games."
Yeah I did a lot of dying in Alan Wake on 360 and then gave up. Now I have it again for PC along with American Nightmare. LOL
OK, I think I'm getting:
I knwo of aome of these but what would you all recommend for halloween titles besides slender?
Definitely Amnesia and the Penumbra games. From what Blake says The Cat Lady too. :)
Thanks,Sonic! I'm always scrounging around for good deals!
That's ok Shirley, always happy to help. LOL